02 · Denials

Who says no, and what happens next

2,464,072 standard requests were denied across the 233 filings in Medicare Advantage that publish counts (of 286), a 9.0% rateⓘ. Four ways to read that number: whether urgent requests fare better or worse and how long decisions take, who issued the denials, whether size changes the rate, and how many denials were ever tested on appeal.

Market
01 · Urgent requests and the clock

When the request is urgent

Expedited requests are the ones a doctor marked as time-critical, and the rule puts a clock on both kinds of decisionⓘ. Four pictures of what payers published against it: how long standard and expedited decisions actually take, whether urgent requests are denied more often than routine ones, and whether a filing's own mean and median tell the same story.

88
of 185 filings deny expedited requests more often than standard ones
3
publish a standard mean over 7 days the filings
1
publish an expedited mean over 72 hours the filings
105
publish a mean more than three times their own median, or the reverseⓘ
Standard decisions click a bar for its filings
Published mean time to decision, against the 7-day clock · 273 filings publish one
29
117
33
68
23
3
0–1
1–2
2–3
3–5
5–7
over 7
days; the orange bar is past the clock.
Expedited decisions click a bar for its filings
Published mean time to decision, against the 72-hour clock · 254 filings publish one
87
52
29
80
5
1
0–6
6–12
12–24
24–48
48–72
over 72
hours; the orange bar is past the clock.
Urgent against routine, 185 filings with 100+ expedited requests click a point for the filing
Standard denial rate across, expedited denial rate up, both to 60%. The dashed line is where the two agree; every point above it is a plan that says no more often when the doctor said it was urgent.
015%30%45%60% standard denial rate
● 88 deny urgent requests more often ● 97 deny them less often
Standard: mean against median click a point for the filing
The two figures a filing publishes for the same standard decisions. Median across, mean up, both on a log scale. On the dashed line the two agree; far from it, one filing's two figures do not.
the clock — 7 days, both axes
0110100 days
● mean past the clock ● mean and median three times apart ● 266 filings publish both ● 103 published a zero — drawn on the axis
Expedited: mean against median click a point for the filing
The two figures a filing publishes for the same expedited decisions. Median across, mean up, both on a log scale. On the dashed line the two agree; far from it, one filing's two figures do not.
the clock — 72 hours, both axes
01101001000 hours
● mean past the clock ● mean and median three times apart ● 253 filings publish both ● 135 published a zero — drawn on the axis

The filings behind the charts

Expedited denied more often than standard, the widest gaps

Plan
Organization
Standard
Expedited
Std mean · median
Exp mean · median
Gap
Johns Hopkins Advantage MD (PPO) - Contract H3890 Medicare Advantage
Johns Hopkins Medicine
14.7%
58.4%
3.0 · 1.0 d
— · —
+43.7 pts
Johns Hopkins Advantage MD (HMO) - Contract H1225 Medicare Advantage
Johns Hopkins Medicine
16.1%
56.3%
4.0 · 1.0 d
— · —
+40.3 pts
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H3794 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
11.9%
44.9%
0.0 · 1.2 d
0.0 · 19.2 h
+33.0 pts
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H7464 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
11.9%
38.1%
1.0 · 2.1 d
0.0 · 12.0 h
+26.3 pts
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H3387 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
11.5%
34.2%
0.0 · 1.4 d
0.0 · 9.6 h
+22.7 pts
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H2247 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
11.3%
26.6%
2.0 · 3.0 d
0.0 · 12.0 h
+15.3 pts
MetroPlus Medicare (H0423) Medicare Advantage
MetroPlus Health Plan
12.0%
26.8%
2.3 · 0.1 d
34.3 · 20.9 h
+14.7 pts
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H2445 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
13.2%
26.9%
1.0 · 3.0 d
0.0 · 14.4 h
+13.7 pts
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H0169 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
13.5%
26.9%
0.0 · 1.9 d
0.0 · 14.4 h
+13.4 pts
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H0421 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
14.4%
25.8%
1.0 · 3.4 d
0.0 · 14.4 h
+11.4 pts
Excellus BCBS Medicare HMO Medicare Advantage
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield
4.9%
16.0%
0.9 · 0.0 d
14.4 · 4.8 h
+11.1 pts
Humana H1036 Medicare Advantage
Humana
7.0%
17.4%
1.0 · 0.0 d
9.0 · 0.0 h
+10.3 pts

Against the clock, and against themselves

Plan
Organization
Standard
Expedited
Std mean · median
Exp mean · median
Flag
Mass General Brigham Advantage Secure HMO-POS Medicare Advantage
Mass General Brigham
—
—
7.3 · 1.0 d
36.0 · 30.0 h
standard mean over 7 days
mean and median three times apart
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest Medicare Advantage
Kaiser Permanente
—
—
3.7 · 0.8 d
14.0 · 1.0 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
Independent Health Medicare H3344 Medicare Advantage
Independent Health
—
—
2.3 · 0.0 d
10.5 · 1.0 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
Kaiser Permanente Hawaii Medicare Advantage
Kaiser Permanente
—
—
1.9 · 0.6 d
6.0 · 1.0 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of Washington Medicare Advantage
Kaiser Permanente
—
—
1.0 · 0.2 d
17.0 · 2.0 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H0421 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
—
—
1.0 · 3.4 d
0.0 · 14.4 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
Geisinger Health Plan (all lines of business, aggregated) Medicare Advantage
Geisinger Health
—
—
0.8 · 0.0 d
0.7 · 0.0 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H0169 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
—
—
0.0 · 1.9 d
0.0 · 14.4 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H0543 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
—
—
0.0 · 2.4 d
0.0 · 12.0 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H0609 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
—
—
0.0 · 1.4 d
0.0 · 7.2 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H0624 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
—
—
0.0 · 0.9 d
0.0 · 7.2 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage - Contract H0710 Medicare Advantage
UnitedHealth Group
—
—
0.0 · 0.9 d
0.0 · 2.4 h
mean and median three times apart
mean and median three times apart
02 · Who denies the most

Organizations, by denials issued

Standard denials summed across every filing the organization published that carries counts. The rate beside each is that organization's own volume-weighted rate.

Plans with the most denials

Denial rate by stateⓘ

click a state for its filings
Alaska: not publishedAlabama: not publishedArkansas: not publishedArizona: 12.9%California: 6.3%Colorado: 9.6%Connecticut: not publishedDistrict of Columbia: not publishedDelaware: 12.4%Florida: not publishedGeorgia: 3.1%Hawaii: 7.1%Iowa: not publishedIdaho: not publishedIllinois: not publishedIndiana: not publishedKansas: 12.6%Kentucky: not publishedLouisiana: not publishedMassachusetts: 11.6%Maryland: 7.7%Maine: 6.4%Michigan: 8.5%Minnesota: 32.5%Missouri: not publishedMississippi: not publishedMontana: not publishedNorth Carolina: not publishedNorth Dakota: not publishedNebraska: not publishedNew Hampshire: not publishedNew Jersey: not publishedNew Mexico: not publishedNevada: not publishedNew York: 8.0%Ohio: not publishedOklahoma: not publishedOregon: 12.6%Pennsylvania: 6.1%Rhode Island: not publishedSouth Carolina: not publishedSouth Dakota: not publishedTennessee: not publishedTexas: 17.8%Utah: not publishedVirginia: 5.1%Vermont: not publishedWashington: 6.1%Wisconsin: 12.2%West Virginia: 6.9%Wyoming: not published
≤ 6.3%6.3% – 7.7%7.7% – 11.6%11.6% – 12.6%> 12.6%not published
03 · Scale and scrutiny

Does a bigger plan say no more often?

Every filing with 100 or more standard requests: request volume across (log scale), denial rate up, coloured by market. A plan far above its neighbours of the same size and market is the one to read.

Denial rate against request volume, 224 filings click a point for the filing
1001K10K100K1M requests
● Medicare Advantage
Median rate by market and size bandⓘ
Medicare Advantage 100–1K 9.2% 25
Medicare Advantage 1K–10K 10.0% 49
Medicare Advantage 10K–100K 11.9% 99
Medicare Advantage 100K+ 7.8% 51

Highest for their sizeⓘ

04 · The appeal gap

Most denials are never tested

Among filings that publish appeal counts (155 of them), 5.6% of standard denials were appealedⓘ, and 73.6% of those appeals overturned the denial. An overturn rate describes the denials someone fought; the denials nobody fought are the larger number, and it is listed here.

1.4M
standard denials in filings that report appeals the filings
77K
appeals filed · 5.6% of denials
73.6%
of appeals overturned the denial
1.3M
denials never appealedⓘ

Everything on this page is computed from the published counts in the filings; the plan pages show the source document for each figure. Where a plan published a rate without counts it cannot appear here, because a rate nobody can check is not a number of denials.